{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, home prices in the U.S. consistently exceeded those from the previous year every month. However, that trend has now come to an end. The latest national statistics for October indicate that the median sale price of homes has decreased slightly in comparison to last year, marking the first annual decrease since spring 2023. Concurrently, the inventory of available homes has reached its highest level since early 2020, while pending sales have fallen to a level not seen in over a decade (apart from the early pandemic). Approximately 20% of active listings have experienced price reductions.

Nevertheless, the cost of borrowing has risen once again. The average interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range in the past week following a brief period of decline. As buyers begin to gain negotiating power, many still find monthly payments burdensome.

This situation creates a unique opportunity. With sellers receiving fewer offers and properties remaining on the market longer, they may increasingly view the listing price and offered terms as negotiable starting points. If you're searching for a home this winter, consider what aspects may be open for negotiation and how to approach these discussions with your agent and lender.

Understanding Small Price Declines

A national price dip of less than half a percent does not indicate a market crash, nor does it imply that prices are dropping in every region. Certain high-end coastal markets with limited inventory are still experiencing significant price increases, while some large metropolitan areas in the South and West have seen price reductions of several percent compared to last year. The performance of your local market is far more relevant than overall national trends.

The national data signals a shift in market dynamics. As homes linger on the market and multiple listings compete for a dwindling pool of buyers, sellers may become more amenable to negotiations. This willingness is often reflected not only in pricing but also in the terms of the sale.

Price Is Just One Area for Negotiation

While many buyers concentrate solely on the sale price, in a high-interest-rate climate, the monthly payment and upfront cash needed at closing can significantly affect overall affordability. A reduction of a few thousand dollars in the sale price only marginally impacts the loan amount. Reallocating that same money elsewhere can sometimes provide greater relief to your finances. In a slower market, typical negotiation points might include:

  • A purchase price lower than the list price
  • A seller credit to assist with closing costs
  • Completion of necessary repairs before closing, or offering a credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller-sponsored funds to help reduce your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or timeline that aligns with your schedule
  • Inclusions of items such as appliances or window treatments with the home

Your agent understands how local sellers are reacting and can direct you toward prioritizing these elements in your offer. It's best to focus on the aspects that will create the most significant impact on your situation.

The Role of Closing Cost Credits

Closing costs typically account for a few percent of the loan amount and need to be covered in addition to your initial down payment. For many first-time buyers, sourcing this amount can prove challenging. A seller credit can help offset some of those costs, reducing the amount you need to bring to closing.

There are limitations to consider. Different loan programs impose caps on the amount a seller can contribute, generally ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price depending on the loan type and down payment size. Moreover, a credit typically cannot exceed your actual closing costs. It's wise to check with your lender early regarding what your specific loan permits to ensure any requests in your offer comply with the regulations.

Understanding Rate Buydowns

With interest rates now back above 7%, assistance from sellers in the form of interest rate reductions can be especially beneficial. There are two primary types of buyouts.

A permanent buydown involves the use of discount points paid at closing to lower the interest rate throughout the loan duration. Each point represents 1% of the loan amount, and the rate reduction varies by lender and market conditions. For those planning to hold the loan for several years, a permanent buydown can be advantageous.

A temporary buydown reduces payments for the initial year or two. In a common structure, your rate could be two percentage points lower in the first year and one percentage point lower in the second, before reverting to the standard rate afterward. For instance, with a $350,000 30-year mortgage at approximately 7.34%, your monthly principal and interest payment would be about $2,409. A temporary buydown could lower your first year's payment to approximately $1,952 and your second-year payment to around $2,176, returning to the full payment in year three. This arrangement can cost around $8,000, which a seller might prefer to provide rather than decreasing the home's price by a similar amount.

Although a temporary buydown can help initially, it's not a long-term solution. Ensure that you're comfortable with what your payment would be once the discount period is over, as lenders generally qualify you based on the full rate. If interest rates drop later, refinancing might become an option, although there are no guarantees regarding timing or rates.

Importance of Home Inspections

In previous competitive markets, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limit their requests to secure a property. However, in a slower market, there is less pressure to forgo these important safety checks. A comprehensive home inspection allows you to assess the state of essential components such as the roof, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, and electrical systems before making a commitment.

If the inspection reveals issues, your agent can guide you in whether to request repairs, negotiate a price adjustment, or ask for a credit. Opting for a credit can sometimes be easier than managing seller-led repairs, as it gives you control over who completes the work and how it is done, but you need to consider the specific issue and the requirements of your loan.

Preparing Your Financing

Having leverage in negotiations is ineffective without solid financing. When sellers are faced with multiple offers, they will likely prefer the buyer who seems most likely to close the deal. Before you start your serious search, obtain complete preapproval instead of a basic prequalification, determine your maximum comfortable monthly obligation, rather than just the highest loan amount, and compare offers from various lenders. Additionally, inquire with lenders about their handling of seller credits or rate buyouts to avoid surprises later on.

Key Questions for Your Agent

  • How long are properties in this area staying on the market, and how frequently are price reductions taking place?
  • Would a price reduction, seller credit towards closing costs, or a rate buydown be more beneficial for my budget?
  • How does the specific condition and past of this home influence what I should request?
  • What contingencies should I include in my offer for my protection?

Final Thoughts

While softer market conditions do not automatically equate to lower prices, especially with increasing mortgage rates, they do offer well-prepared buyers an opportunity to negotiate terms more favorably. With appropriate financing, a clear understanding of priorities, and advice from your agent and lender, you could secure better terms than were imaginable just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message